Culture & ideas

Trump, the Debate, & Theology of Laughter

Donald Trump's humor in the first presidential debate illustrates the two God-given functions of laughter: uniting people and tearing down false power.

Watch the episode

That is a Founders Porter, if you were wondering—it is very good.

Today we are looking at Donald Trump, the presidential debates, and the purpose of laughter. The first presidential debate took place recently, and of course we have to say it was a joke. It was absolutely horrible, and we should all be embarrassed that this is the state of political discourse.

Humor in the Debate

Tabling that comment, there was something fascinating about what went on. Donald Trump is very rhetorically effective, and one of his effective rhetorical properties is his humor. He is very funny. Multiple times in the debate he made Joe Biden and Chris Wallace laugh—like genuinely laugh. Not laughing at him or laughing out of embarrassment, but genuinely laugh:

“When needed, I wear a mask. … I don’t wear masks like him. Every time you see him, he’s got a mask. He could be speaking two hundred feet away from it, and he shows up with the biggest mask I’ve ever seen.”

And when Wallace attempted to intervene to let Vice President Biden speak, Trump kept going about Biden holding much smaller events where nobody shows up.

The Two Functions of Laughter

There is almost a superpower in the ability to make people laugh, because laughing can have two functions. In fact, it does have two functions.

One is a unitive function. When you are sharing laughter with someone, you are creating a bond where your body is uncontrollably moving, and there is this excess of energy when you are laughing with someone else and you find this thing funny. It creates this real bond.

But laughter can also perform a destructive function too. And it can do both of these at the same time. That is why this is a wildly, wildly amazing thing that God created. When you laugh at something, all of a sudden that thing ceases to have as much power. You are not giving it as much weight.

Tearing Down and Building Up

These two functions of laughter, I think, have been lost for many years within Christianity. That is why something like The Babylon Bee has been so wonderful: it is able to do both of these things, both to unite and to tear down and ridicule.

This matches the two functions in Jeremiah chapter 1, where God calls Jeremiah to tear down and to destroy, and to build and to plant. These are two fundamental functions of our work—the work that God has given to us. All of us tend to do one or the other, but both is what we need to be doing. And laughter is one of those things that can do both.

Gravity and Sin

I remember one of my mentors in high school. I was struggling with something—some sin in my life, and I do not even remember what it was—and I called him and was talking on the phone. I had a long discourse where I was talking for about five minutes, going off on X, Y, and Z. When I was finished, he just started to laugh.

At first, I was very angry. I thought, “This is a serious thing I am dealing with, and you are laughing about it? You are making light of it?”

And that was precisely what he was doing. I was attributing too much weight to it. When you attribute so much weight to something, you are giving it gravity in your life. You should not be giving sin so much gravity. The gravity should be Christ, the gospel, and grace. That is what should have the central gravity.

By his laughing, he was both creating a bond with me—after I got over it and realized what was going on—and also tearing down my false evaluation of the sin in my life. It is a fascinating picture of the function of humor in life.

Watch the original episode.